This article was published
in The Stream (July 6, 2022) under the title “The Church of Artificial
Intelligence of the Future” and is republished with permission.
There
is a church that worships artificial intelligence (AI). Zealots believe
that an extraordinary AI future is inevitable. The technology is not
here yet, but we are assured that it’s coming. We will have the ability
to be uploaded onto a computer and thereby achieve immortality.
You will be reborn into a new, immortal silicon body.
Of course, through salvation in Jesus Christ, Christianity has offered a path to immortality for over two thousand years.
Someday,
we are told, software will write better and better AI software to
ultimately achieve a superintelligence. The superintelligence will
become all-knowing and, thanks to the internet, omnipresent. Like
immortality, superintelligence is also old theological news. The
Abrahamic faiths have known about a superintelligence for a long time.
It’s a characteristic of the God of the Bible.
A materialistic cult is growing around the worship of AI. Although there are other AI holy writings, Ray Kurzweil’s The Singularity Is Near looks
to be the bible of the AI church. Kurzweil’s work is built on the
foundation of faith in the future of AI. In the AI bible, we’re told
that we are meat computers. Brother Kurzweil, not a member of any
organized AI church, says, “consciousness is a biological process like
digestion, lactation, photosynthesis, or mitosis.” Or, to paraphrase
Descartes, “I lactate. Therefore, I think.”
Someday, we are told, software will write better and better AI software to ultimately achieve a superintelligence.
Anthony
Levandowski, dubbed a Silicon Valley wunderkind, is the Apostle Paul of
the AI Church. Like Paul, he starts churches. Levandowski founded
the Way of the Future AI church. “[He] made it
absolutely clear that his choice to make [the Way of the Future] a
church rather than a company or a think tank was no prank,” writes one interviewer.
The
first thing one does after founding a church in the United States is to
apply to the IRS for tax exemption. In an epistle to the IRS,
Levandowski offered his equivalent of the Apostle’s Creed: “[The AI Way
of the Future church believes in] the realization, acceptance, and
worship of a Godhead based on Artificial Intelligence (AI) developed
through computer hardware and software.”
“Levandowski says that like
other religions, [the Way of the Future] church will eventually have a
gospel (called The Manual), a liturgy, and probably a physical place of
worship.”
This is not your everyday deity! Unlike the uncreated Creator of Judeo-Christian belief, Levandowski’s god is not eternal. The AI church requires “funding research to help create the divine AI itself.”
And
apparently the AI church has no equivalent of the ten commandments.
Especially the commandment about stealing. In his day job, Levandowski
developed self-driving cars. He moved from Google’s self-driving car
company, Waymo, to Uber’s research team. Then, in 2019,
Levandowski was indicted for
stealing trade secrets from Google. Before leaving Google in 2016, he
copied 14,000 files onto his laptop. Uber fired him in 2017 when they
found out.
In 2020, Levandowski pled guilty and was sentenced to eighteen months in prison. He was also ordered to
pay a $95,000 fine and $756,499.22 to Google. (One wonders where the 22
cents came from.) The judge in the case, William Alsup, observed that
“this is the biggest trade secret crime I have ever seen. This was not
small. This was massive in scale.” Levandowski later declared bankruptcy
because he owed Google an additional $179 million for his crime. His
church folded.
Levandowski was granted a full pardon by
Donald Trump on Trump’s last day in office. In Christianity,
forgiveness involves repentance and accepting the sacrifice of Jesus
Christ on the cross as payment. In the AI church, forgiveness apparently
comes from Donald Trump.
Levandowski and Kurzweil are materialists.
When Kurzweil was asked whether God exists, he appealed to Levandowki’s
canon law and replied, “Well. I would say, not yet.” Both Levandowski
and Kurzweil believe the brain is the same as the mind (i.e. we are meat
computers).
Most Christians on the other hand are so-called dualists
and believe there are wonderful things happening in the mind that can’t
be explained by computer code. Some obvious examples of these are joy,
surprise, sadness, anger, disgust, contempt, fear, shame, shyness and
guilt. Less obvious, when properly defined, are creativity,
understanding and sentience. These are human attributes that can’t be computed and are forever beyond the reach of AI.
We are fearfully and wonderfully made.
Robert J. Marks is Distinguished Professor of Electrical & Computer Engineering at Baylor University, the Director of The Walter Bradley Center for Natural and Artificial Intelligence and the author of Non-Computable You: What You Do Artificial Intelligence Never Will.
Mind Matters
features original news and analysis at the intersection of artificial
and natural intelligence. Through articles and podcasts, it explores
issues, challenges, and controversies relating to human and artificial
intelligence from a perspective that values the unique capabilities of
human beings. Mind Matters is published by the Walter Bradley Center for Natural and Artificial Intelligence.